Climate Change: Media vs. Pope

by Church Militant  •  •  May 2, 2015   

You are not signed in as a Premium user; we rely on Premium users to support our news reporting. Sign in or Sign up today!

By Shane Schaetzel

“We are all responsible for the protection and care of the environment. This responsibility knows no boundaries.”

Do you find these words provocative? They were spoken by the Pope. Does a Pope have no business delving into the subject of environmentalism? You might be inclined to think these words came from Pope Francis, but they didn't. They were actually uttered by Pope Benedict XVI in his Message for the Celebration of the World Day of Peace, on January 1, 2010.

His Holiness didn't stop there. He continued:

In 1990 John Paul II had spoken of an “ecological crisis” and, in highlighting its primarily ethical character, pointed to the “urgent moral need for a new solidarity.” ... Can we remain indifferent before the problems associated with such realities as climate change …? Can we disregard the growing phenomenon of “environmental refugees,” people who are forced by the degradation of their natural habitat to forsake it …?

What was this “ecological crisis” the Holy Father spoke of? He was speaking of what is commonly referred to as “climate change.” The title of this message was “If You Want to Cultivate Peace, Protect Creation,” and you can view the whole message on the Vatican website here.

Judging by these quotes, it appears Pope Benedict XVI was not only a believer in climate change, but also an advocate for economic corrections to the problem. Such quotes may come as a shock to Catholics in the United States, particularly faithful and orthodox Catholics, some of whom are inclined to the notion that environmental protection is a “liberal idea” and has no place in the teaching of the Church.

The point of this commentary is not to champion climate change or the alleged science behind it. Frankly, I couldn't care less. As an asthmatic, I've always opposed air pollution of any type, and so whether or not carbon emissions are raising global temperatures is of little consequence to me.

My opposition to carbon emissions began more than 40 years ago, long before it was trendy. It began as a child, when I found myself literally unable to breathe in my childhood home of Los Angeles county. Climate change means very little to a person struggling for air. In a very real sense, I am one of those “environmental refugees” Pope Benedict XVI spoke of in 2010. I was forced to leave my childhood home as a young man back in 1993, to seek refuge in the Ozark Mountains of Southern Missouri, where the air is much less polluted.

The real point I want to address here has nothing to do with the environment, air pollution, climate change or the pope's teaching on it. The real issue I want to address here is how the words of our Holy Father are being played by the media to create artificial division between Catholics.

In the last major address before his retirement, Pope Benedict XVI warned us about the influence of the media over society during and after the Second Vatican Council. He cited the mainstream media for creating an artificial council that bore little resemblance to the actual council that took place in Rome. Because of this, he lamented, the “hermeneutic of rupture” was born, which resulted in great upheavals the Church still has yet to recover from. This “council of the media” corrupted the minds of Catholics, and turned them against the intentions of Catholic leaders. You can read the entire address on the Vatican website here.

I'll take His Holiness' words a step further by insisting this “council of the media” never ended, but continues on today. And just as the media has changed in recent years to incorporate libertarian and neoconservative voices, so too the “council of the media” has changed as well to reflect this.

I started this commentary with Pope Benedict XVI's words on the environment and climate change. So now I come full circle with Pope Francis' much-anticipated upcoming encyclical on the same subject. I obviously can't comment on an encyclical that hasn't been released to the public yet, but again, that's not the point of this commentary. The point of this commentary is to warn my fellow Catholics about what is going on in the “council of the media” right now, even as you are reading this.

Some new media sources, ideologically opposed to the theory of man-made climate change, are already undermining the moral authority of our Holy Father, and they are poised to attack just as soon as the encyclical is released. Likewise, traditional media, in favor of man-made climate change theory, are likely to use the upcoming encyclical as a license to advocate whatever socialist or population-control schemes they think they can get away with. The “council of the media” will report this encyclical to be “groundbreaking” and “revolutionary” — even if it isn't.

My warning here is to beware the “council of the media” and ignore much of what the press has to say about Pope Francis in regards to this. We should listen to our Holy Father, not media outlets and political hacks. The popes have been trying to tell us something important about the environment for a while now, and it's a message that transcends scientific theories and controversial methods of data collection.

My only concern is that the Pope is Catholic, and as we've seen from two previous popes, talking about the moral implications of man's influence on the environment appears to be a very Catholic thing to do. These things do have an impact on people, and that in turn has an impact on souls.

Shane Schaetzel is a published author and columnist for Christian print magazines and online publications. He is a freelance writer and the creator of FullyChristian.Com — The random musings of a Catholic in the Ozarks.


Have a news tip? Submit news to our tip line.

We rely on you to support our news reporting. Please donate today.
By commenting on you acknowledge you have read and agreed to our comment posting guidelines