Fr. Perrone Maintains Innocence

News: US News
Print Friendly and PDF
by Christine Niles, M.St. (Oxon.), J.D.  •  ChurchMilitant.com  •  August 5, 2019   

Press release from attorney details polygraph test

You are not signed in as a Premium user; we rely on Premium users to support our news reporting. Sign in or Sign up today!

DETROIT (ChurchMilitant.com) - Detroit priest Fr. Eduard Perrone continues to maintain his innocence in the face of an allegation of abuse stretching back four decades.

A statement released Monday by Perrone's attorney, Christopher Kolomjec, offers details about the recent polygraph test administered to the priest, who was placed on leave July 5 after a single, 40-year-old allegation based on a "repressed memory."

Critics claim the suspension is a "political hit job," spearheaded by Msgr. Michael Bugarin, episcopal vicar and delegate for matters of clergy misconduct, who was also involved in removing other orthodox priests in Detroit.

The polygraph was conducted by a former police lieutenant of the Taylor Police Department, Michael Anthony, who specializes in testing alleged sex offenders. He does polygraphs for the U.S. Probation Office and the Michigan Department of Corrections.

Anthony's written report concluded that Perrone's answers were "truthful" and that the test results indicated "NO DECEPTION" (emphasis in original). He also said the results were "very clear, giving him a high degree of confidence in his conclusions." 

Father Perrone passed the exam 'with flying colors' and his results were so unequivocal that they could be used in textbooks.

"Notably, he mentioned that Father Perrone passed the exam 'with flying colors' and noted that Father Perrone's results were so unequivocal that they could be used in textbooks," the statement read.

"Father Perrone is hopeful that the results can be utilized to demonstrate his innocence and
accelerate his reinstatement to full priestly ministry by the Archdiocese of Detroit," it continued.

The statement goes on to give an update on the altar boys who signed affidavits testifying to Perrone's character, with 55 total so far vouching that they never witnessed or heard of any inappropriate behavior from Perrone. Four other individuals who spent significant time around Perrone over the course of 40 years also signed affidavits testifying to his moral integrity.

"We are all altar boys who have served with Fr. Perrone at some point over the years," the affidavit states, going on to note:

  • We have all served at Mass with Fr. Perrone, some of us on a one-on-one basis.
  • Most of us have interacted with him at graduation parties, weddings and other social and community gatherings.
  • Some of us have attended day-long canoe trips.
  • Some of us have attended overnight retreats and traveled with him to out-of-town conferences and events.
  • Some of us have participated in his various children's and adult choirs over the years.
  • Some of us have spent significant time with him, one-on-one, to prepare for liturgical or musical events, or to seek spiritual guidance.
  • Some of us are now married and consider ourselves blessed to have had Fr. Perrone as the celebrant at our weddings.
  • Many of us continue to make Assumption Grotto our home parish, despite long commutes and other inconveniences, and involve our own children in Assumption Grotto activities with children.

"Collectively, we have spent tens of thousands of hours with Fr. Perrone in circumstances like these, among others," the letter continues. "Many of us were vulnerable at some point during this period, due to young age or other factors."

"However, none of us have ever experienced, or observed, any immoral or inappropriate behavior by Fr. Perrone in connection with his interactions with altar boys or any other parishioners," it reads.

The full press release follows:

Father Eduard Perrone Passes Polygraph, Maintains Innocence

Novi, Michigan, August 5, 2019 – Father Eduard Perrone, a priest in the Archdiocese of Detroit and pastor of Assumption Grotto Parish in Detroit, took and passed a polygraph test, and maintains his innocence from the recent, highly publicized, allegations against him. On July 5, 2019, Father Perrone was restricted from exercising all public ministry after the Archdiocese of Detroit determined that a "credible" allegation of sexual misconduct had been made against him.

Father Perrone vigorously denies the allegation and the accuser’s description of events. In an effort to clear his name and accelerate his reinstatement, Father Perrone submitted to a thorough polygraph examination on July 30, 2019.

The examination was conducted by Mr. Michael Anthony (License # 6001000316), at the offices of Kolomjec & Associates, P.C., Father Perrone's civil attorneys. Mr. Anthony is a retired police officer (former Police Lieutenant with the Taylor Police Department in Michigan), and a highly experienced and well-respected polygraph examiner. Among other engagements, he currently performs polygraph services for the United States Probation Office as well as the Michigan Department of Corrections, with a focus on polygraphs related to sex offenses. The examination lasted over 2 hours, during which several polygraphs were completed using questions relevant to the accusations against Father Perrone, specifically, questions regarding the accuser's claims of sexual abuse that were used by the Archdiocese of Detroit to suspend Father Perrone.

Following a thorough analysis of the polygraph results, Mr. Anthony provided a written report concluding that Father Perrone "did not show consistent, significant, physiological reactions to the ... questions, indicating NO DECEPTION," (emphasis in original) and that Father Perrone was being "truthful" in his denial of the alleged sexual misconduct. Mr. Anthony also verbally indicated that Father Perrone’s results were very clear, giving him a high degree of confidence in his conclusions. Notably, he mentioned that Father Perrone passed the exam "with flying colors" and noted that Father Perrone’s results were so unequivocal that they could be used in textbooks.

Father Perrone is hopeful that the results can be utilized to demonstrate his innocence and accelerate his reinstatement to full priestly ministry by the Archdiocese of Detroit. In addition to the positive polygraph results, over 55 current and former altar boys who have served with Father Perrone over the years signed written statements affirming that they have never been subject to any abuse or inappropriate conduct, or heard of or witnessed any such abuse or conduct by Father Perrone. A number of other individuals who have spent significant time with Father Perrone over the last 4 decades, including rectory workers, have also signed written statements indicating that they have never witnessed any inappropriate behavior by Father Perrone.

A fundraiser has been set up for Fr. Perrone's legal defense fund

 

Have a news tip? Submit news to our tip line.


We rely on you to support our news reporting. Please donate today.
By commenting on ChurchMilitant.com you acknowledge you have read and agreed to our comment posting guidelines