Lockdown Lawsuit

News: US News
by Martina Moyski  •  ChurchMilitant.com  •  April 16, 2020   

Michigan governor's 'overbearing restrictions' challenged in court

You are not signed in as a Premium user; we rely on Premium users to support our news reporting. Sign in or Sign up today!

DETROIT (ChurchMilitant.com) - While business shut-downs and stay-at-home mandates are the order of the day, lawsuits against these mandates are becoming more common.

Four Michigan residents filed suit against Democratic Gov. Gretchen Whitmer on Tuesday, arguing her stay-at-home order violates citizens' civil liberties.

Recently extended to May 1, Whitmer's quarantine order requires that Michiganders stay home unless they are shopping for food, seeking medical care or exercising. Most businesses have been forced to close to comply with the order.

Attorney David Helm of Helm Law, PC is representing the Michigan residents in federal court. Helm told Church Militant that "Our position is simply that when the government takes some necessary action which infringes on individual constitutional rights, they must tread lightly and take the least restrictive approach as defined by the Constitution."


"I want to make it clear from the onset of this case that my clients are not saying that there is not a pandemic or that the government does not have some obligation to do something in response," he said. "My clients are further not looking to cash in on the crisis as some have alleged. They simply want to see what we consider to be overbearing restrictions put in place by the executive orders lifted."

Never in the modern history of the United States — even in wartime — has such an invasive action stripping citizens of fundamental rights been taken by a government order.

Governor Whitmer's order, issued April 9, "is unreasonable and goes too far," he concluded.

The lawsuit lists the plaintiffs:

  • Steve Martinko of Oakland County and his company Contender's Tree and Lawn Specialists, Inc. are suing over the financial burden of shutting down the business and of Martinko being unable to access company property. According to the lawsuit, the company is losing hundreds of thousands of dollars in supplies, tree and plant treatments and equipment. "Timing is crucial ... Any delay beyond the first weeks of April may prevent the ability to control dangerous tree and plant diseases and invasive insects," the lawsuit says. The company also had to lay off 15 workers, "irreparably damaging its sterling reputation with its workforce."
  • Michael and Wendy Lackomar of Oakland County, both deemed essential workers, own a cabin in Sanilac County, and under Whitmer's executive order, are not permitted to return to their home in Oakland County — although under the order, people are allowed to return to their homes outside Michigan.
  • Jerry Frost, resident of Roscommon County, has been banned from visiting his girlfriend of 14 years and other family and friends because they do not live together.

For all of the plaintiffs and their claims, Helm says he is invoking the 14th Amendment, which protects life, liberty and property.

"Never in the modern history of the United States — even in wartime — has such an invasive action stripping citizens of fundamental rights been taken by a government order," the lawsuit contends.

President of the Michigan Conservative Coalition (MCC) Roseanne Ponkowski told Church Militant that she celebrated the right of American citizens "to petition our government in a way that we feel best moves our grievance forward."


Ponkowski referred to Operation Gridlock, launched by the MCC, which lawfully protested the governor's order on April 15 with tens of thousands Michiganders jamming the roads surrounding the state Capitol in Lansing.

"We welcome anyone or any organization that furthers the agenda of getting Michigan safely back to work," Ponkowski explained.

Will the courts rule in favor of the Constitution and a free republic or will the court side with naked authoritarianism?

"Moving the Governor off her draconian rules to a place where we can begin to allow people to safely return to work will take several different approaches," she added. "I applaud anyone who is willing to help advance that agenda."

Image
Operation Gridlock, Lansing, April 15, 2020

Helm also said his law firm is bringing a claim at the state level against the governor shortly which will challenge "the mandatory quarantine of the healthy and the travel restrictions which have been held to be a fundamental constitutional right here in the state of Michigan."

Whitmer is facing more than just lawsuits from Michiganders.

In addition to Operation Gridlock, more than 262,864 Michigan residents to date have signed a petition to recall the governor at Change.org and more than 351,000 to date have joined a Facebook group called "Michiganders Against Excessive Quarantine."

A group of Michigan sheriffs announced they will not enforce some of Gov. Whitmer's executive orders.

Sheriffs Mike Borkovich, Ted Schendel, Ken Falk, and Kim Cole of Michigan's 101st District released a press statement on April 15 explaining their decision to place their oath to the Constitution above Whitmer's wishes.

Image
Protesting Whitmer on the steps of the state Capitol (AP)

"We write today to inform the public for our respective counties [Leelanau, Benzie, Manistee, Mason] of our opposition to some of Gov. Whitmer's executive orders. While we understand her desire to protect the public, we question some restrictions that she has imposed as overstepping her executive authority," read the letter signed by each sheriff.

One observer echoing the sentiments of many citizens said that the federal and state lawsuits against Whitmer represent the ultimate test of the courts to rule impartially on the language codified in the Constitution and ask, "Will the courts rule in favor of the Constitution and a free republic or will the court side with naked authoritarianism?"

Ponkowski said, as a Catholic, the hardest part of the shut-down has been "the inability to receive Holy Communion. Not going to Mass has been particularly hard on me, as that is where I also feel closest to Our Lord."

Church Militant phoned the numbers listed at the Michigan.gov. website hoping to speak, if not to the governor, then with a representative, but was unsuccessful "due to a high volume" of calls, according to recordings.

--- Campaign 27425 ---

 

Have a news tip? Submit news to our tip line.


We rely on you to support our news reporting. Please donate today.
By commenting on ChurchMilitant.com you acknowledge you have read and agreed to our comment posting guidelines