McCarrick Victims Suing Vatican

News: US News Print Friendly and PDF
by Phillipe Champlain  •  ChurchMilitant.com  •  November 20, 2020   

Complaint: Policy of cover-up a violation of international law

You are not signed in as a Premium user; we rely on Premium users to support our news reporting. Sign in or Sign up today!

NEWARK, N.J. (ChurchMilitant.com) - The Holy See is being slapped with a lawsuit over sex abuse cover-up.

Image
Homopredator and ex-cardinal Theodore McCarrick

In a virtual press conference Thursday, attorney Jeff Anderson announced he was filing a complaint in federal district court in New Jersey on behalf of four victims of serial homosexual predator, former cardinal Theodore McCarrick.

One of the victims is a priest, but his identity is hidden in this case to shield him from repercussions from his bishop and the Vatican.

In his address, Anderson, who specializes in prosecuting clerical sex abuse cases, detailed the specifics of the lawsuit. He laid blame for McCarrick's decades of predation on minors and young men at the feet of three pontiffs: John Paul II, Benedict XVI and Francis.

"Why is the Vatican named? Because the problems and the source of them — which includes secrecy and hiding of the truth and hiding of the offenders and the perils that exist nationwide and across the globe — all come from Rome," Anderson explained.

"All roads lead there," he continued. "All trails that we have been working to uncover and excavate for almost four decades lead there. Every case that survivors have brought by us and others standing up for the truth and to protect kids ultimately leads to practices and protocols and policies implemented by the Holy See."


In the suit, Anderson explained, "no less than 33 cardinals are named and identified as either condoning or complicit in the pattern of sexual abuse by McCarrick. ... Three popes, 33 cardinals, countless bishops — literally hundreds of bishops — thus implicated in this lawsuit."

Secret settlement agreements with victims have been used to silence the victims and their families and to protect the abuser from criminal prosecution.

The lawsuit accuses the Vatican of perpetuating sex abuse through cover-up:

Secret settlement agreements with victims have been used to silence the victims and their families and to protect the abuser from criminal prosecution by United States and state authorities. This practice was designed to shield defendant Holy See from "scandal," and has been mandated not only in the United States but throughout the world, including North and South America, Europe and Australia. Defendant Holy See is responsible for the historically verified practice of the hierarchy, including the bishops, moving sexually abusive priests to areas where allegations of the offender's abusive conduct were not known. Defendant Holy See has never taken appropriate or effective steps to remove sexually abusive priests from the ministry ... .

While the "public" policy of Defendant Holy See is to forbid child sexual abuse by priests and clerics within its control, the actual "private" or secret policy is to harbor and protect its abusive priests, clerics, bishops, archbishops, cardinals, agents and employees from public disclosure and prosecution in order to maintain the supreme pontiff's rightful claim of control and thereby ensure that its parishioners, followers and financial contributors will keep confidence in the institution, continue to view defendant Holy See and the supreme pontiff as deserving of allegiance and, therefore, continue to contribute money and property to defendant Holy See. 

The suit also accuses the Vatican of violating international law. It notes that in 1990, the Holy See ratified the Convention on the Rights of the Child (CRC) — a United Nations treaty laying out civil, political and social rights for children — and is therefore legally bound by the terms of the accord.

"In January 2014, defendant Holy See was called to respond to questions about its record in protecting children from sexual violence," it explains. The following month, the CRC released a report condemning the Vatican's failure to protect minors from "sexual abuse committed by members of the Catholic churches ... with clerics having been involved in the sexual abuse of tens of thousands of children worldwide." 


Church Militant explains the complicity and coverup not found in the Vatican's McCarrick Report


"The United Nations has expressed ... concerns with defendant Holy See's compliance with the CRC," the suit notes, accusing the Vatican of consistently placing "the preservation and reputation of the Church and the protection of perpetrators above the best interest of children."

These concerns include the fact that the Vatican's internal law has "allowed the vast majority of abusers and almost all those who concealed child sexual abuse to escape judicial proceedings in states where the abuses were committed," and "imposes a code of silence on all members of the clergy," which has both "prevented child sexual abuse from being reported to law enforcement authorities" and "caused those members who have reported to be ostracized, demoted or fired, while priests who have refused to denounce child abusers have been congratulated and promoted within the Catholic Church."

Anderson closed Thursday's press conference with a direct appeal to Pope Francis, "Engage with us ... to open up the iron gates of secrecy protecting offenders!"

--- Campaign 31877 ---

 

Have a news tip? Submit news to our tip line.


We rely on you to support our news reporting. Please donate today.
By commenting on ChurchMilitant.com you acknowledge you have read and agreed to our comment posting guidelines