No Gay Subculture?

News: Commentary
Print Friendly and PDF
by Bradley Eli, M.Div., Ma.Th.  •  •  January 17, 2019   

Catholic petition asks questions Bp. McElroy won't answer

You are not signed in as a Premium user; we rely on Premium users to support our news reporting. Sign in or Sign up today!

The so-called listening sessions hosted by the bishop of San Diego were billed as an opportunity to get answers on the exploding clerical sex abuse crisis. Faithful Catholics were tossed out of the sessions, however, for asking the wrong questions — so they formed a petition to voice these questions.

Bishop Robert McElroy announced these question and answer sessions last August. When they rolled out in October and early November, Church Militant was flooded with tips on the tight security and forced removal of many Catholics who asked questions at these open sessions concerning the problem of a gay subculture among the clergy and its contribution to the clerical sex abuse crisis.

Because most of their questions were ignored, these faithful Catholics started a group called Concerned Catholics of San Diego and launched a petition that represents their questions that McElroy refuses to answer. Their questions include:

  1. Will you publicly request the resignation of bishops who have covered up for or failed to remove from ministry priests who sexually abused minors or vulnerable or subordinate adults?
  2. Why haven't you publicly called for the resignation of Cardinal Wuerl?
  3. Why did you not act on the information regarding Archbishop McCarrick's misdeeds when A.W. Richard Sipe presented them to you? His letter is very thorough.
  4. Since becoming a bishop, what information have you received (of any kind, including rumors) about sexual misconduct by priests or bishops? What actions, if any, did you take when learning of that information?
  5. Have any of our seminarians experienced sexual advances from other seminarians or seminary formators? If so, what did you do about it?

For asking these questions, faithful Catholics were forcibly removed from McElroy's presence. The diocesan spokesman, Kevin Eckery, was asked about the removals. Even though the expulsions were captured on video, nevertheless, Eckery denied it.

"This is the Church," Eckery offered, "We don't forcibly remove anybody."

He then admitted that people were removed for the sake of facilitating a discussion.

"They had attended the last one as well and they were mildly disruptive," claimed Eckery. "So that we could actually have a quality discussion, they were asked to leave."

Many faithful Catholics noted there wasn't much of a discussion because of the Catholics that were asked to leave before getting to ask their questions, and many of the questions that were asked went unanswered. One such man who was removed was Kevin Crammer.

"I am grateful that the bishop is having these sessions," Crammer told FOX 5, "and that we have the opportunity to engage with him in discussion, but I do feel like there were a lot of questions that were left unanswered."

Watch the panel discuss questions that Bp. McElroy refuses to answer in The Download—No Gay Subculture?

--- Campaign 31538 ---


Have a news tip? Submit news to our tip line.

We rely on you to support our news reporting. Please donate today.
By commenting on you acknowledge you have read and agreed to our comment posting guidelines