One Priest’s Message to Seminarians on National Abuse Scandal

by Church Militant  •  •  August 20, 2018   

A homily by Fr. Matthew Kauth, rector of St. Joseph College Seminary

You are not signed in as a Premium user; you are viewing the free version of this program. Premium users have access to full-length programs with limited commercials and receive a 10% discount in the store! Sign up for only one day for the low cost of $1.99. Click the button below.

By Fr. Matthew Kauth

The faithful are asking the bishops for a response. It caused me to reflect on my own. What is my response? How could I give just one?

I have an emotional response — the same as any sane man. I am sickened, disgusted, angry, horrified. What I am not is surprised. I am not shocked. I have no longer any trust in princes. In 20 years as a priest, I have seen too much of man and too much of the devil. I am not shocked — shock ended many years ago.

In 20 years as a priest, I have seen too much of man and too much of the devil.

Priests are not allowed to speak on certain topics. Perhaps it is better to say they can do so, but only at their own peril. The moment the god of personal choice is attacked, the weapons of social media launch an assault from all sides with the cry of outrage. I know because I lived through it. I know the price you pay for touching certain diseases in the Body of Christ and speaking about them plainly.


One disease has been made untouchable, unmentionable as a sickness. Thus, are we shocked to find its infection into all that is sacred? In the words of St. Catherine, we have been taught to apply the ointment of mercy when what was needed was the knife of justice. What should have been cauterized over the last hundred years has been soothed. We are not allowed to speak about diseased attractions. You are to accommodate them, accept them — in some dioceses, celebrate them — in some circles, promote them. But you must never take up arms against them.

And yet we are shocked to find their effects riddled into our sanctuaries? I am not shocked, nor is anyone who has lived inside the heart of the Church for these many decades. My shock ended when I was young and wondering what my response would be when I first encountered the stench of rotting flesh on the Mystical Body. What would my response be when I had all these violent emotions?

Cut oneself off from the body or attempt to fight the cancer. The former seems easy to do but it won't do — not if you know that the body is His body.

What does one ever do with emotion if it is not to rule us? Use it, harness it, form it, direct it. We are part of a diseased body not of our own making. The options were clear for me when I was 19 years old. Cut oneself off from the body or attempt to fight the cancer. The former seems easy to do but it won't do — not if you know that the body is His body. I knew the Church was divine — that she was Christ's — and I knew that Her members were sinful because I knew myself a sinner. But what to do about this disease? To fight this leprosy requires a saint and I am not one. So, my passions gave way to another response — I thought.

I had an intellectual response. I sat down and thought about the battle as Christ commanded us to do before entering into it. Could it be won? What does one do when surrounded on every side? What does one do when the odds are impossible? Only what one can. What could He do with me? I who stood there with a crust of bread and the head of a fish but what is that for so many? He didn't care. Feed my sheep.

My response to this scandal started a long time ago. It started when I decided to be a priest. I was shocked before seminary but no longer. I knew what I was heading into. I wanted to run into a burning building. I wanted to jump on the boat that seemed to be sinking. I encountered the evil long ago, and I wanted to attack it. Foolhardy, perhaps. Only He could inspire such a thing. He inspires to walk on water. But what would that do? What is one weak man against so many? But I was not alone. I simply didn't know how many others there were.

The intellectual response grew in my will and became a fire in me. It was time for a practical response beyond the priesthood itself. Words are not needed. Deeds are needed. I wanted to fight fire with holy fire. I wanted to respond. What deed? I believe that what I have experienced in 25 years of attempting to follow Christ was in some sense to prepare me for this deed, this response.

My response is this: a seminary. My response is you, a new priesthood. Whatever we do we are not doing what was done, that has not worked. When a vocation is born, it is pure, like water from a spring. We cannot attempt to purify the water after it has become brackish. We must start at the source — the building of solid men for the priesthood. People say we are too traditional? I don't know what that means. When something new doesn't work, one has to circle back and revivify what once did. Solid formation according to the mind of the Church, not the mind of the age the Church is in: perennial, tradition — period. We don't want what has been done for the last 100 years. We are not doing that. We want Him to make all things new, not try more new things.

If people ask me what my response is I will tell them silently by pointing to you. You have that same look in your eye. You want to be trained, equipped, formed, strengthened for this epic war. Are you scared? Perhaps you should be. But did we not choose as our motto the words spoken to Joseph? Do not be afraid to take the Church as your own, to guard and protect her from her enemies — inside and out. Do not be afraid to stand with Christ at the cross of this scourge. Do you think they are just words we use to sound pious? It kills. Do not be afraid to nurture the Church with your own sacrifice. You are blessed to have a bishop who will stand with you, who is a vigilant gatekeeper. I will stand with you. The priests who work here will stand with you. We may fall but we will fall together.

Rid the Church of diseased attractions first by building men of virtue and purity.

Yet I have one more response, for it is not only men that are necessary. Ever have I been drawn to the tower of David, the tower of ivory. Ever have I been strengthened by the mere thought of the Woman and inspired by her to give that which I thought was not possible. You must cling to her. She purifies all who are in her presence. The ever-virgin, Blessed Mary. In my desire to help build men I had not thought that I would have a hand in building women. What I had not expected is that the Blessed Mother would give me her daughters, give them to me to help form them in this charism of reparation and sanctification of priests — the Daughters of the Virgin Mother.

Thus, while I point to you with one hand, I point to them with the other. That is my response — purity. Rid the Church of diseased attractions first by building men of virtue and purity. Inspire priests to stay at Calvary and not flee. There is enmity between the Woman and the enemy. There is enmity between the dragon and her daughters. The serpent hates them, and he hates you. You will be hated by all who call Satan their father. Do not fear to be hated. You will be loved by your Heavenly Father. What is my response? You are my response.

Finally, a word for your families. Tell them to cover you in prayer. Tell them to sacrifice for you still. Tell them they are needed in this work of formation and preparation. As they helped to form you, tell them not to stop but to pray and sacrifice for you. You cannot go into this alone. Tell them to support the priesthood of Jesus Christ and to do so by demanding sanctity of Her priests and support those priests who are attempting to build. Tell them to love the priesthood, for you may be one of them. Tell them that this seminary is their home too, and they may come when they are in need of strength or just simply want to strengthen you. This is not a one-man affair. This is the Church: fathers, mothers, sons, daughters and lay faithful.

We have chosen to break ground on the 15th of September. For a long time, I wanted to break ground on the 22nd of August in honor of Our Lady's Queenship and Immaculate Heart. Yet in the end, we were delayed, and now I know why. We offer this groundbreaking and this seminary to the Sorrowful Mother, in reparation. We pledge to enter the narrow way and commit ourselves to being faithful sons. Let us be the men that turn that sorrow into joy and gladden Our Mother's heart.

Go now. Go to your home parishes. Strengthen the faithful. If they ask you your response, just point to yourself. You will give your life in response. Someone must die that others may live. And above all, clothed in the power of Christ, nolite timere!


Have a news tip? Submit news to our tip line.

We rely on you to support our news reporting. Please donate today.