Become an informed Catholic. Click here to join the fight.
The initiative, a higher committee established in Abu Dhabi Aug. 19 to ensure the objectives of the "Document on Human Fraternity for World Peace and Living Together" are met, includes Vatican and Muslim officials.
Pope Francis praised the new initiative in a press release from the Holy See on Wednesday:
Although sadly evil, hatred and division often make news, there is a hidden sea of goodness that is growing and leads us to hope in dialogue, reciprocal knowledge and the possibility of building, together with the followers of other religions and all men and women of good will, a world of fraternity and peace.
Church Militant spoke with Robert Spencer, the director of Jihad Watch and a Shillman fellow at the David Horowitz Freedom Center, about the document and this new initiative.
"This 'Document on Human Fraternity' is full of outrageously false and misleading statements," he said. "One is the claim that terrorism is due to 'an accumulation of incorrect interpretations of religious texts and to policies linked to hunger, poverty, injustice, oppression and pride.'"
Spencer explained how this claim about terrorism is false and misleading:
If terrorists' interpretations of Islamic religious texts are incorrect, then so are the interpretations of those texts by all the schools of Islamic jurisprudence, all of which, without exception, teach the necessity of the Islamic community worldwide to wage war against unbelievers and subjugate them under the hegemony of Islamic law.
Bishop Miguel Guixot, president of the Pontifical Council for Interreligious Dialogue and a member of the higher committee, offered a different interpretation of "Document on Human Fraternity" in an interview with Vatican News:
I think the Abu Dhabi declaration is a global appeal to the 'civilization of love' that contrasts with those who want a clash of civilizations! Prayer, dialogue, respect and solidarity are the only winning weapons against terrorism, fundamentalism and all kinds of war and violence. They are weapons that are part of the spiritual arsenals of all religions. Peace is a precious good, an aspiration that lives in the heart of every man, a believer or not, and which should inspire every human action.
Spencer disagrees that dialogue is a winning weapon against terrorism: "Pope Francis' much-vaunted 'dialogue' has never saved one Christian from being persecuted by Muslims, or prevented one church from being destroyed by jihadis. Nor will it ever do these things, as it is based on fantasy and wishful thinking, not on reality."
In a recent interview with LifeSiteNews, Bp. Athanasius Schneider said that the phrase "Human Fraternity" sounds nice but has led to a betrayal of the Gospel:
The problem is of the utmost seriousness, because under the rhetorically beautiful and intellectually seductive phrase "Human Fraternity," men in the Church today are in fact promoting the neglect of the first Commandment of the Decalogue and the betrayal of the core of the Gospel. However noble such aims as "human fraternity" and "world peace" may be, they cannot be promoted at the cost of relativizing the truth of the uniqueness of Jesus Christ and of His Church and of undermining the first Commandment of the Decalogue.
The committee includes Bp. Guixot; Msgr. Yoannis Gaid, personal secretary to Pope Francis; Mohamed Hussein Mahrasawi, president of Al-Azhar University; Judge Mohamed Salam, advisor to the grand imam; Mohamed Al Mubarak, Abu Dhabi's chairman of the Department of Culture and Tourism; Dr. Sultan Al Rumaithi, secretary-general of the Muslim Council of Elders; and Yasser Hareb Al Muhairi, author and media personality.