Pope Hypes Alarmism on Melting Glaciers

News: World News Print Friendly and PDF
by Jules Gomes  •  ChurchMilitant.com  •  September 18, 2020   

Scientific journals debunk pontiff's climate apocalypticism

You are not signed in as a Premium user; we rely on Premium users to support our news reporting. Sign in or Sign up today!

VATICAN CITY (ChurchMilitant.com) - Pope Francis ratcheted up his climate change alarmism to apocalyptic levels at his Wednesday public audience, warning that "two great glaciers in Antarctica near the Amundsen Sea" are "about to fall."

Image
Pope Francis greeting youths at his Wednesday audience

"It will be terrible because the sea level will rise and this will bring many, many difficulties and cause so much harm," the pontiff predicted.

"And why?" Francis asked. "Because of global warming, not caring for the environment, not caring for the common home," he categorically declared, attributing the cause for the melting glaciers to anthropogenic climate change.  

Claiming he had just read about the imminent catastrophic collapse of the glaciers in the newspaper, Francis repeated his now-familiar refrain: "God always forgives; we sometimes forgive; nature never forgives."

However, of the many papers published in scientific journals on the melting glaciers, none of them attribute the cause to global warming, Church Militant has learned.

In comments to Church Militant, journalist James Delingpole, who helped expose the "Climategate scandal," lambasted the pope for "embracing paganism — specifically Gaia worship — and left-wing politics."

"But there's no evidence here that he understands science," lamented Delingpole, author of The Little Green Book of Eco-Fascism: The Left's Plan to Frighten Your Kids, Drive Up Energy Costs and Hike Your Taxes.  

"Under West Antarctica's ice sheet is the largest volcanic region on earth with nearly 100 volcanoes, some nearly 4000 meters high. What effect does Francis think molten lava and fumaroles will have on an ice sheet? Does he believe volcanoes are somehow a consequence of Western industrial civilization?" Delingpole asked.


Pine Island Glacier and Thwaites Glacier in the Amundsen Sea embayment "are tearing loose from their restraints," the left-wing Washington Post reported Monday, "increasing the threat of large-scale sea-level rise."

Again, the scientific study on which the newspaper based its story did not attribute the cause for the acceleration of the "ice shelf instability" to "climate change" or "global warming."

The Washington Post blamed the melting glaciers on "climate change" by obtaining a quote from pro-climate-change glaciologist Isabella Velicogna.

What effect does Francis think molten lava and fumaroles will have on an ice sheet? Does he believe volcanoes are somehow a consequence of Western industrial civilization?

Velicogna said, "When the ice shelves are damaged by climate change, as we saw in the Antarctic Peninsula in the last several decades, their buttressing effect is reduced and the ice streams speed up and raise sea levels."

The scientific study published in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences (PNAS) also concluded that "assessing how much and how fast both glaciers will weaken if these changes continue remains a major uncertainty."

It acknowledged that "many of the processes that control their ice shelf weakening and grounding line retreat are not well understood."

Image
Map of West Antarctica showing the Thwaites Glacier

Two other scientific papers published last week in the journal Cryosphere, which were based on a 2019 expedition to the glaciers, also did not attribute the cause of the melting to global warming.

A 2002 study published by the International Glaciological Society reported the retreat of the ice but concluded that their observations "were not sufficient to determine the cause of the changes." The study did not mention anthropogenic global warming.

Moreover, scientists admitted that the glaciers are "not likely to collapse in the next century; they are simply too big to fail right now."

A "numerical model" study in 2014 concluded that "collapse in the different simulations" was "within the range of 200 to 900 years."

Pope Francis also called for a "fraternal relationship with creation" in his address, which failed to mention Jesus even once and pleaded for "penance" towards "indigenous peoples" to "repair the evil we have done to them."

There's no evidence here that Pope Francis understands science.

In 2010, Rajendra Pachauri, head of the United Nations' Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC), warned that the Himalayan glaciers would mostly likely melt away by 2035, and the ice would vanish "perhaps sooner" as a result of global warming.

The claims were soon discredited to the IPCC's embarrassment. 

Even the left-wing Guardian newspaper was forced to admit: "'Glaciergate' has brought into the open splits between authors of the four different IPCC reports, produced every five or so years."

--- Campaign 31877 ---

 

Have a news tip? Submit news to our tip line.


We rely on you to support our news reporting. Please donate today.
By commenting on ChurchMilitant.com you acknowledge you have read and agreed to our comment posting guidelines