Pope’s Pro-Abortion Pick Sparks Blame Game

News: World News
by Jules Gomes  •  ChurchMilitant.com  •  November 11, 2022   

Speculation grows that Francis could reverse teaching on contraception

You are not signed in as a Premium user; you are viewing the free version of this program. Premium users have access to full-length programs with limited commercials and receive a 10% discount in the store! Sign up for only one day for the low cost of $1.99. Click the button below.

VATICAN CITY (ChurchMilitant.com) - Pope Francis' appointment of a pro-abortion atheist to the Pontifical Academy for Life has sparked a blame game among papal bigwigs. 

Abp. Paglia, president of the Pontifical Academy for Life

The finger-pointing comes amid mounting speculation over a new papal document, which is expected to reverse the Church's ban on contraception articulated by Pope Paul VI in his pro-life encyclical Humanae Vitae

Weigel Absolves Francis

Writing in First Things on the Feast of All Souls, papal biographer George Weigel blamed PAL chief Abp. Vincenzo Paglia for presiding over the "deconstruction of the Pontifical Academy for Life as Pope St. John Paul II created it."

Weigel did not mention Francis' role in appointing Mariana Mazzucato, but he attacked Paglia as "not the man I knew some three decades ago." 

"Archbishop Paglia has recently agreed to the appointment of Professor Mariana Mazzucato, a pro-abortion economist, as a member of the pontifical academy, in the name of 'fruitful interdisciplinary, intercultural, and interreligious dialogue,'" Weigel shrieked.

Excoriating the archbishop's defense of Mazzucato's appointment as "the most shallow, and indeed duplicitous, nonsense," Weigel asked if it was legitimate to appoint heretics or anti-Semites to Vatican bodies in the name of "dialogue" about Christianity or Judaism.

Humanae Vitae is a 'reformable doctrine.'  

Ironically, Weigel had earlier called for the abortion-tainted COVID jab to be distributed rapidly.

Weigel's daughter Dr. Gwyneth Anne Spaeder, who is married to Dr. Jeffrey Spaeder, the chief medical and scientific officer of IQVIA, a company linked to the pharmaceutical industry and to the manufacturers of the COVID jab, targeted Abp. Carlo Maria Viganò for his position against the jab.   


It is widely known that the president merely rubber-stamps the pope's nominations to the academy. Moreover, the academy's statutes, rewritten in 2016 by Francis, clearly state that ordinary members "are appointed for a term of five years by the Holy Father."

Pope Praises Pro-Abortionist

Pope Francis has praised Mazzucato in his book Let Us Dream, describing her writing as "not ideological" and moving "beyond the polarization of free market capitalism and state socialism" with "a concern that all of humanity have access to land, lodging and labor."

On his return flight from Bahrain, Francis categorically stated that he had chosen the "great economist" Mariana Mazzucato as a full member of the Pontifical Academy for Life "to give a little more humanity to it."

I am called to evaluate academics according to the criteria of this world.

The pope told reporters that he was triggering a "revolution" by appointing women to top positions in the Vatican "because women know how to find the right way; they know how to move forward."

Francis also appointed pro-abortion activists — bioethicist Dr. Roberto Dell'Oro and former Botswanan health minister Sheila Dinotshe Tlou — to the prestigious academy created by Pope St. John Paul II to defend the value of human life.

Paglia Blames Pope

On Thursday, Paglia laid the blame for the appointment at Francis' doorstep, writing that "the pope himself reiterated that it was a pontifical appointment, as happens with every appointment of an ordinary academic [member of the academy]."

Paglia agreed that the body he chairs "played a role in the long procedure that led to the choice," but he insisted that the pope had "expressly made it clear" that the academy was to "broaden the spectrum of the areas of its research to include fields hitherto little or not at all explored."

Francis at an assembly of the Pontifical Academy for Life

"I am called to evaluate academics according to the criteria of this world," and "not based on any tweets or likes," the archbishop wrote, arguing that Mazzucato's appointment had triggered controversy based on her use of social media and not because of her writings.

"Certainly, no source of her scientific thought has ever questioned the Magisterium of the Church," Paglia stressed. "Mazzucato is an economist whose works are public and famous."

Following global outrage over Mazzucato's appointment, Paglia defended the atheist economist, insisting that "her tweets may have been 'pro-choice,' but they were not 'pro-abortion.'" 

The archbishop repeated his "pro-choice" language in his defense of Mazzucato, arguing that support for the economist's "pro-choice political position" can "be deduced, exclusively, from likes and the forwarding of tweets."

Dogma, morality, is always in a path of development, but development in the same direction.

Paglia slammed Mazzucato's critics for attacking her pro-abortion position rather than evaluating her economic theories, claiming the academy had appointed her "as a resource for identifying ways to alleviate inequalities in the world and, therefore, to favor life." 

In a second interview with The Tablet, a left-wing Catholic journal, the archbishop criticized debates around abortion and euthanasia for becoming "ideologized" and said the academy was "interested in demolishing" the "ideological prejudices that contaminate reflection, contaminate public opinion" and "prevent broad engagement across the board." 

Paglia stressed that the academy was opposed to abortion but could not ignore "attacks on life that come from inequality," citing two million children dying of malnutrition every year. 

Reversing Contraception?

In the interview, the archbishop gave the strongest indication thus far that Francis was poised to reverse the ban on artificial contraception. "I believe that the day will come when Pope Francis or the next pope [will do so]," he remarked. "Certainly, we have to address it."

Paglia castigated "those who oppose discussing these issues," as infected with "a pathology" and a "sick faith" that "runs the risk of blocking the Spirit." 

The president of the Pontifical Academy for Life reasoned how a couple might adhere legalistically to Humanae Vitae by rejecting artificial contraception but might use only natural methods and choose not to have any children. 

Earlier, when asked on his return flight from Canada, if the Church could change its teaching on contraception, Pope Francis replied that "dogma, morality, is always in a path of development, but development in the same direction." 

Father Maurizio Chiodi, a moral theologian at the John Paul II Theological Institute for Marriage and Family Sciences has argued that Humanae Vitae is a "reformable doctrine," claiming it's not infallible teaching.  

Chiodi, whom Pope Francis had appointed an ordinary member of the Pontifical Academy for Life in 2017, argued that it would be an act of "responsibility" to use artificial contraception where "natural methods are impossible or unfeasible."

In October, Chiodi pushed for a "theological discussion" on Humanae Vitae, observing that "the possibility of dissent" is overdue.

--- Campaign 32075 ---


Have a news tip? Submit news to our tip line.

We rely on you to support our news reporting. Please donate today.
By commenting on ChurchMilitant.com you acknowledge you have read and agreed to our comment posting guidelines

Loading Comments